The Adoption Agency Checklist
   
 Introduction
 The Checklist
 Guide to Agency and Facilitator Web Sites
 Photolistings and Ethics
 Why the Bad Stories Must Be Told
 Proposed Adoption Reforms
 Links

 The Porter's Guatemalan Nightmare

 Lora Cullipher's Experience with Reaching Out Thru International Adoption

 

This applies to all international adoptions in general. Specifics by country and program will vary.

1. Get references and contact them. Get references who are at different stages in the process and who have completed adoptions at different times. This is important to detect any changes in treatment as the process progresses and any changes in the agency/facilitator/attorney. Know what questions to ask. Try to get references of people who had problems along the way but were able to overcome them and complete a successful adoption so you can see how the agency responds to and handles problems.

2. Join local and internet adoptive parent support groups. Network as much as you possibly can. Listen, learn and ask questions. There are no stupid questions, just people too stupid to ask them. List serves and the various Internet bulletin boards are invaluable. Use search engines such as Google, Dogpile, Yahoo and Webferret to search for information on any agency you are considering. Search for complaints. Search the names of agency principals, workers and facilitators. Several hours invested in research can save you tens of thousands of dollars and a lifetime of emotional pain.

3. Check an adoption professional or agency out with the licensing authority in its home state. Ask for a record of complaints. The authority is usually the state's Dept. of Social Services or Dept. of Health and Human Services, except in the case of an adoption agency operating under a lawyer's license, in which case the authority is the state's Bar Association. Remember, facilitators are usually unlicensed, unregulated and even illegal in some states. A good source for this and other state specific information is www.stateinformation.com.

4. Check an adoption professional or agency with its home state's Attorney General's office. Ask if there are any criminal actions or complaints.

5. You used to be able to check for complaints at www.theadoptionguide.com. This was an award winning site to use as a resource to help avoid adoption fraud and to see some of the less than stellar experiences people have had with various adoption workers. Although the URL for this site was sold to Adoptive Families magazine after it was shut down due to litigation, if you use the Wayback Machine at www.archive.org, you can access archived versions of this site and still make use of this resource.


6. Since many of the agencies mentioned there have programs in other places besides Latin America, you might find mention of the agency you are considering there. Also, the sister site to The Adoption Guide, www.adoptionnews.org, featured a "rate your adoption" survey that I helped design and a page where you can search by agency for the ratings given to that agency by survey respondents. Unfortunately, this site was also shut down over threats of litigation, but again, archived versions are available through the Wayback Machine at www.archive.org. Three other sites where you can see how clients rate agencies and their experiences are: www.eeadopt.org/home/services/agency/agency_registry/index.html,

www.adoptachild.org, and http://adoptingfromrussia.com/. Additionally, Ethica, which promotes ethical adoptions, has an information-packed site and many features geared towards consumer protection. They can be found at www.ethicanet.org. They have also started a new Coalition for Change to promote ethical adoption reforms.


7. Check with the foreign country's US consulate. They may be aware of any problems with the professionals you are considering.

8. Check with the
US consulate in the foreign country. The INS officer there is the one responsible for issuing orphan visas and should be very attuned as to what adoption agencies, facilitators and attorneys have a history of problems.

9. Consider hiring or consulting an experienced and reputable adoption attorney in your area to protect your emotional and financial interests. While some may view this as an unnecessary budget-breaking additional expense, spending a few thousand dollars here can sometimes save you from losing tens of thousands of dollars to adoption fraud or scams. The promise of a desperately desired child or the bond to a photograph or video of one can often blind you to any red flags that crop up. A less costly measure of protection is to have any contracts reviewed by a contract attorney before signing. Remember, any contract can be amended or negotiated to better protect and serve your interests. As time has passed since I first assembled this checklist, this step has proven to be or increasing importance. Remember, aAll contracts are negotiable. DO NOT SIGN ANY CONTRACT THAT INCLUDES A GAG CLAUSE THAT LIMITS YOUR RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH.

10. Use the BCIS and State Dept. websites to be up on all the rules, regulations and situations in whatever country you are considering. If anyone you are working with is not on the same page as the authorities, consider it a red enough flag to make everyone stop and get on the same page. In programs where you are allowed to visit the referred child prior to finalizing the adoption, take all possible measures to insure that the adoption will, in fact, be finalized, prior to visiting. This means that you should be sure the child meets the BCIS definition of an orphan and that other country-specific criteria, such as DNA matching in
Guatemala, have been met.

11. Be cautious if you are offered a referral before you have a completed and approved homestudy.

12. Be wary if you are asked to sign a blank Power of Attorney. The Power of Attorney should only be one page, if not, you should sign both pages so alterations and substitutions can be avoided.

13a. If the agency networks with another party (agency, facilitator or attorney) for the program you select, make sure that is disclosed to you, along with the identity of the other party, before you pay any non-refundable fees, in case this other party is one with whom you prefer not to work. You might want to apply this checklist to this other party as well. Ask the agency if all their employees, consultants and parties they may network with here and agents in a foreign country have undergone criminal background checks. This is where you should ask your agency about how they review and select their foreign sources along with how long a relationship they have had with their foreign sources. There may not be a good substitute for a hands-on, agency program that includes frequent visits by the agency program directors to the foreign countries in which they have programs, to monitor their foreign agents and sources in person.

13b. With implementation of the Hague Treaty around the corner in the US and elsewhere, or already a reality elsewhere, ask about compliance and changes in programs and procedures that the agency anticipates. This could give you an idea if the agency has considered the future and its long term viability. Additionally, with shut downs and moratoriums happening with little or no notice, be very clear with the agency on alternatives and refund policies should this occur.

13c. If the agency is essentially a one-man operation, you should also be clear on what plans are in place should the primary contact have a personal, family or medical situation arise where he or she can no longer perform his or her functions. Find out what contingency plans exist and who will take over should this occur. There have been cases where a one-man agency or its programs deteriorate rapidly because such events occurred and there was no back-up plan in place.

13d. Ask to see a copy of the agency's audited financial statement. This is so you can see if the agency is in good financial standings and is financially stable. You don't want an agency that goes out of business while you are in the middle of an adoption with them.

14. Try to work with people who are paid fees for services rather than on a contingency basis. Adoption workers paid on contingency have the income incentive for volume and quick adoption completions, similar to a commission for completed, delivered deals. Service may suffer under this kind of plan.

15. Try to get an itemized breakdown of where the foreign fees go and try to confirm that in the foreign country. What you are trying to learn is if the agency is marking-up and keeping the difference between actual foreign fees and what they charge you, or enagaging in unethical practices, without disclosing this to you. Another consideration here is that you want to know where every penny of your adoption money goes so that you can be assured that things like corruption, baby-buying and profiteering were not part of your adoption process. This is what is mean when your hear terminology that references a "transparent" process.


16. In cases and countries where the biological mother is identified, ask the agency what kind of counseling and support their program offers to biological mothers. The answer may help reveal the agency's commitment to fair and ethical practices. Additionally, the level of service provided a biological mother, along with the level of service provided a child in an orphanage or foster care, should be a reflection of the level of service provided an adoptive family.

17. The greatest number of complaints against adoption agencies concern the placement of children with undisclosed special medical and psychological issues. Placing a child with these kinds of issues in a family that is unequipped emotionally, physically and financially to handle them, along with being uneducated and untrained about these issues, will often tear apart the family and further damage the child. Agencies that intentionally place children in situations like this should be held criminally liable. They can do no greater disservice to their clients and the orphans. I urge every prospective adoptive family to seek out only those agencies that have programs to educate you about potential issues unique to internationally adopted children and who make every possible effort to obtain as much background information on their referrals as possible. Prospective adoptive families should ask for copies of all available medical reports prior to accepting a referral. Both originals and translations should be provided so that the prospective adoptive family can verify the accuracy of the translation, as this has been shown to be a problem with medical report translations in some countries. If your requests for such information are denied without due cause, spread the word and take your business elsewhere. If things don't look and feel right, get independent second and third opinions. If you are still uncomfortable with the information you receive, either ask for more or decline the referral. Failed and disrupted adoptions are a growing problem that we can strive to prevent.

Take care and enjoy your ride on the adoption roller coaster.

David